Prediction markets came under scrutiny at a November 17 hearing for two CFTC nominees. Democrat Matthew Rowland expressed sympathy for states and tribes challenging sports contracts. Republican Nathan Anonick declined to say whether an NFL-linked contract constituted sports betting.
President Donald Trump nominated both candidates on November 12. Rowland said the agency should weigh the public benefits of certain contracts against their economic usefulness. He also said he was interested in shaping rules for prediction markets.
Why the CFTC Faces Challenges Over Prediction Markets
The CFTC claims exclusive authority over event contracts on federally registered exchanges. States and tribes dispute that claim for sports offerings. Courts have reached conflicting conclusions on whether federal law overrides state gambling restrictions.
Anonick said he would follow any future Supreme Court ruling. Senator Tina Smith challenged his characterization of the issue as emotional, citing tribal gaming protections and states’ authority over sports betting.
What the Nominees Said About Agency Oversight
Senator Raphael Warnock questioned links between the Trump family and prediction markets. Both nominees rejected the possibility of preferential treatment, saying the law should apply equally regardless of political connections.
A lawmaker said the CFTC had lost about a quarter of its staff. Both candidates supported hiring when needed and restoring the five-member commission.
The Senate committee did not hold a confirmation vote during the hearing. Both nominees still need Senate approval to join CFTC Chairman Michael Selig. The agency currently lists Selig as its only commissioner.

