At their U.S. Senate confirmation hearing, President Donald Trump’s two nominees for commissioner of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission did not strongly criticize the agency’s approach to prediction markets. However, the Democratic nominee questioned whether the industry serves the public interest.
At Tuesday’s hearing before the Senate Agriculture Committee, Democratic nominee Matthew Rowland said federal law directs the agency to assess the public interest in trading certain event contracts. He added that the CFTC should "think long and hard about balancing the public interest against the kind of economic usefulness of these contracts."
The industry includes betting platforms operated by Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase and other exchanges regulated by the CFTC. It is engaged in an existential legal fight: some federal courts have found that the business model is akin to a casino and subject to state regulation. Many states have sued the businesses, alleging they violate state gambling laws. The firms and their regulator, the CFTC, argue that their status as federal derivatives exchanges means they are not subject to state laws. One federal court has agreed with that argument.
Nominee Nathan Anonick, who has served on the Senate committee’s Republican staff, said the resulting legal uncertainty makes prediction market regulation a complex question. He said he would follow any potential U.S. Supreme Court ruling that resolves the issue. "It's a very charged, emotional issue, and I appreciate how sensitive it is," he said.
Senator Tina Smith, a Minnesota Democrat, pushed back, saying, "I don't think that this is an emotional issue. I think this is a legal issue. I think it is a core legal tenet that is laid out in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, as well as the rights of states to regulate sports betting."
The CFTC has pursued lawsuits to protect its authority over prediction markets and has proposed regulations tailored to the emerging industry. Rowland said he hoped he would get the chance to work on them.
Rowland and Anonick faced more than an hour of questions about the CFTC’s future, with mostly Democratic committee members in attendance. Both had worked on the committee staff, on opposite sides of the aisle, and lawmakers greeted them cordially at Tuesday’s hearing.
President Donald Trump nominated the two last week as a pair of candidates approved by lawmakers who are widely expected to be confirmed before the congressional session ends. If confirmed, they will join the commission’s sole current member, Chairman Mike Selig.

