For years, the standard story about DeFi security has focused on code: audit the smart contracts, fix the bugs, and the money stays safe.
Andrew O’Neill of S&P Global Ratings offers a less reassuring view. In a recent interview, he said the people and systems surrounding decentralized finance can pose greater security risks than the smart contracts themselves.
That matters because S&P has incorporated this idea into a formal framework for assessing DeFi lending products.
The weak link has a keyboard
O’Neill’s argument is straightforward. A smart contract is a program that runs automatically on a blockchain and can be audited line by line. The people who manage access keys, approve upgrades, and make governance decisions are much harder to audit.
S&P’s research supports that view. On November 17, 2026, the ratings agency published findings that most hacking losses over the past five years stemmed from three areas: failures in operational risk management, weak governance, and access-control problems.
Access control determines who is permitted to move funds or change a protocol’s settings. If it fails, even a perfectly written contract can be drained.
The figures are significant. S&P says annual losses linked to these vulnerabilities ranged from 7 to 30 basis points of on-chain asset value. A basis point is one hundredth of a percentage point, meaning this amounts to between 0.07% and 0.30% of assets lost each year.
Those figures may seem small at first. But S&P’s research found they significantly exceed the tolerance levels considered acceptable for critical financial infrastructure.
Recent months have illustrated the point. Incidents across various DeFi platforms in March and April 2026 resulted in approximately $600 million in cumulative losses, according to S&P’s research.
A new rulebook for lending vaults
O’Neill’s comments are not an isolated opinion. They are central to S&P’s Vault Risk Assessment framework, known as VRA, which the agency launched in October 2026.
VRA is intended to provide forward-looking risk analysis of DeFi lending vaults. These are pools where depositors place assets to be lent out according to a set strategy. Many use a curator, a manager who decides where deposited funds go and what limits apply.
The framework assesses vaults in six risk categories, including curator risk, operational security, and governance.
O’Neill also challenged a popular DeFi talking point. Supporters often argue that on-chain activity makes risks visible to everyone. O’Neill’s view is that understanding risk requires more than transparency. You can observe every transaction in real time and still overlook that one person controls the keys.
In his view, assessing the human factors behind a protocol is necessary to reduce security threats effectively. Ledger visibility alone does not show who might mishandle it.
Why S&P is paying attention now
The growth curve helps explain the timing. Deposits in digital-asset lending vaults rose from $1.5 billion in September 2024 to about $10 billion by September 2026. That is more than a sixfold increase in two years.
VRA is also part of a broader expansion by S&P Global into digital assets. The firm has expanded its coverage to include assessments of stablecoins and protocols such as Sky.
Traditional credit analysts have long considered management quality alongside balance sheets. S&P is now applying a similar approach to on-chain products, weighing the curator and governance structure as seriously as the code.
What this means for DeFi users and builders
For investors, the clearest implication is a change to the due diligence checklist. A clean smart contract audit has long been considered a mark of safety. S&P’s framework suggests it is necessary, but far from enough.
Depositors may start asking different questions: Who controls the admin keys? How are upgrades approved? What happens if a curator makes a bad decision?
For builders, the message is clear. DeFi has spent years arguing that code can replace trusted intermediaries. S&P’s research suggests that, in practice, much of the risk still comes from the people involved.

