Making sense of crypto.
NBTCNEWS

Ripple’s Stuart Alderoty says formal crypto rules can outlast any SEC chair

Ripple Chief Legal Officer Stuart Alderoty urged regulators to establish crypto policy through formal, public rulemaking, arguing written rules are more likely to survive leadership changes than policies shaped through lawsuits. The company made that case in an October comment letter on a proposed SEC framework, seeking durable rules for the broader market after years of litigation and more than $150 million in regulatory clarity efforts.

By NBTC3 min read
Ripple’s Stuart Alderoty says formal crypto rules can outlast any SEC chair

Ripple’s top lawyer has a straightforward message for Washington: To make crypto rules last, put them in writing.

Ripple Chief Legal Officer Stuart Alderoty says careful rulemaking can endure across administrations. He argues that the SEC’s approach under Gary Gensler does not.

Rules on paper versus rules by lawsuit

Alderoty’s argument hinges on the difference between two ways regulators can set policy. Formal rulemaking involves an agency proposing written rules, inviting public feedback and finalizing them. The alternative is case-by-case enforcement, in which policy takes shape through the entities the agency chooses to sue.

Alderoty has said enforcement-driven policy tends to change when leadership turns over. A new chair takes office, priorities shift, and the industry is left guessing again.

He has also argued that ambiguous enforcement actions drove innovation offshore. When builders cannot determine what is legal in the US, some simply establish themselves elsewhere.

Ripple’s comment letter and the Capitol Crypto Forum

Ripple formally stated its position on October 20, 2026. That day, the company submitted a comment letter to the SEC on the agency’s proposed Regulation Crypto Assets.

The letter supported rulemaking, while noting some reservations. Ripple called for changes to the proposal to help ensure the resulting rules remain effective over the long term.

Alderoty has repeatedly emphasized that the SEC has clear authority to implement the proposed regulations. That matters because challenges to an agency’s authority are among the main ways new rules can be delayed or struck down.

Alderoty brought the message to the Capitol Crypto Forum on November 19, 2026. He warned that congressional oversight could grow if political dynamics shift, particularly regarding leadership on banking matters.

He specifically cited Sen. Elizabeth Warren, predicting greater congressional oversight if she gains more influence.

Why Ripple has a stake in durability

Few companies have a closer personal connection to SEC enforcement than Ripple. Its long-running legal battle with the agency over $XRP has shaped how the entire industry views regulation.

In 2023, a federal court ruled that $XRP is not a security. In March 2026, joint guidance from the SEC and the CFTC classified $XRP as a digital commodity.

The effort came at a cost. Ripple has spent over $150 million on regulatory clarity efforts since 2020.

That figure helps explain Alderoty’s focus on permanence. After spending years and nine figures to secure clarity, the company has reason to want it enshrined in durable rules rather than left to the discretion of whoever leads the agency next.

The court ruling and commodity classification addressed Ripple’s own token. Formal rulemaking would establish a written framework for the wider market, a different and broader aim.

share preview

Sharing is disabled in this private preview. Nothing has been sent.

Sources