Making sense of crypto.
NBTCNEWS

Judge allows DRAM cartel lawsuit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to proceed

A federal judge has allowed consumers’ and small businesses’ antitrust case against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to move into discovery, finding their allegations of coordinated DRAM supply cuts plausible enough to proceed. The ruling is not a finding of wrongdoing: the companies say their production decisions reflected market conditions, and the plaintiffs must still establish coordination rather than independent responses to demand.

By NBTC4 min read
Judge allows DRAM cartel lawsuit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to proceed

For roughly a year, the only parties with meaningful influence over memory chip prices were the three companies selling the chips. Now a federal judge in San Jose has a place at the table, too.

On November 14, 2026, US District Judge Noël Wise declined to dismiss a class-action antitrust lawsuit against Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix and Micron Technology. The decision opens the door to discovery, when internal emails and planning documents may become available.

What the lawsuit alleges

The lawsuit was filed by 17 consumers and small businesses. They allege the three chipmakers conspired to limit the supply of conventional DRAM, the everyday memory used in laptops, phones and servers.

The plaintiffs are indirect purchasers. They did not buy chips directly from Samsung, SK Hynix or Micron, but paid for them as components in finished products. Filed on June 25, 2026, the complaint seeks damages and injunctive relief.

The market concentration at issue is substantial. The three defendants together accounted for over 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025.

The alleged timeline

The complaint says production cuts began in late 2022 and followed a clear sequence. SK Hynix reportedly acted first, on Oct. 26, 2022.

Micron allegedly followed about three weeks later. Samsung reportedly joined in April 2023.

The plaintiffs also cite a simultaneous shift in factory capacity. They allege the companies moved production away from conventional DRAM and toward high-bandwidth memory, or HBM.

HBM is a premium type of memory, stacked and designed to deliver data quickly to AI processors. It has higher margins, making it a more attractive product for a chipmaker answerable to shareholders.

According to the complaint, the shift squeezed supply of conventional DRAM. Prices reportedly surged by estimates ranging from approximately 500% to as high as 697%.

Why the judge kept the case alive

A motion to dismiss is a defendant's bid to end a case before it gets underway. The basic argument is that even if the plaintiffs' claims were true, they would not amount to a legal violation.

Judge Wise found the allegations plausible. That means the plaintiffs presented enough to be allowed to seek evidence.

The ruling also distinguished this lawsuit from an earlier case that was dismissed. The judge said the specific circumstances alleged in this case set it apart, allowing it to proceed where the earlier suit did not.

That distinction is important. Antitrust lawsuits often fail at this stage because parallel conduct, such as companies cutting output at the same time, is not automatically illegal. Plaintiffs generally need to show evidence suggesting agreement rather than coincidence.

The ruling does not mean the companies did anything wrong. No liability has been established.

The defendants say their production decisions reflected changing market conditions, not collusion. Their formal responses to the lawsuit are due by December 7, 2026. The first case-management conference is scheduled for January 12, 2027.

A familiar cast

The memory industry has faced cartel accusations before. The defendants were involved in a previous DRAM price-fixing cartel that operated from 1998 to 2002 and ended with significant penalties.

The circumstances are also quite different this time. Two decades ago, the focus was PC memory. Today, the alleged motive is tied to AI, as demand for HBM from data center builders gives manufacturers a lucrative reason to shift capacity.

That gives the defense a straightforward argument. A company seeking higher margins in a booming product category is, on its face, acting as companies do. The plaintiffs must show that the shift was coordinated rather than made independently.

What this means

For investors in Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, the immediate consequence is legal uncertainty rather than a verdict. Discovery can be lengthy and costly, and documents that emerge could shape public perception well before a trial.

The key dates are clear. The December 7, 2026 deadline will show how the companies set out their defense in writing. The January 12, 2027 case-management conference will begin to establish the pace of discovery.

share preview

Sharing is disabled in this private preview. Nothing has been sent.

Sources