Close Menu
  • Coins
    • Bitcoin
    • Ethereum
    • Altcoins
    • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • DeFi
  • Metaverse
  • Regulation
  • Other
    • Exchanges
    • ICO
    • GameFi
    • Mining
    • Legal
  • MarketCap
What's Hot

Tom Lee Says Ethereum Could Be the Next Bitcoin

05/07/2025

UK’s OpenTrade Raises $7M to Expand Stablecoin Yield Access in Inflation-Hit Markets

05/07/2025

Ripple Donates $25 Million Worth of RLUSD, Here’s Where It Is Going

05/07/2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Back to NBTC homepage
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
X (Twitter) Telegram Facebook LinkedIn RSS
NBTC News
  • Coins
    1. Bitcoin
    2. Ethereum
    3. Altcoins
    4. NFT
    5. View All

    20,000+ Bitcoin Bought in Just Two Days – Whales Expecting New ATH?

    05/07/2025

    Strong Technicals and Institutional Confidence Drive Bullish Outlook

    05/07/2025

    What Does the Pullback in Bitcoin Tell Us? What to Expect from BTC Next? Experienced Analyst Evaluated!

    05/07/2025

    Trump’s Company Announces Bitcoin Move

    05/07/2025

    Tom Lee Says Ethereum Could Be the Next Bitcoin

    05/07/2025

    Why Is Ether Struggling Near $2,400 Even as More Firms Add ETH to Their Treasuries?

    05/07/2025

    Ethereum dev Zack Cole launches initiative to fund ‘tokenless’ projects, promote ETH burning mechanisms

    05/07/2025

    Ethereum (ETH) Price Prediction for July 3

    05/07/2025

    Ripple Donates $25 Million Worth of RLUSD, Here’s Where It Is Going

    05/07/2025

    Unknown Whale Liquidates Billions of Shiba Inu (SHIB) on Bybit

    05/07/2025

    Crucial Warning Issued by SHIB Team, Recommendation Follows

    05/07/2025

    DAG MD Says XRP Is Heavily Undervalued, Could See Massive Upside If It Handles Just 10% of SWIFT’s Daily Transactions

    05/07/2025

    NFT Market Sees Recovery, Records 17.23% in Weekly Sales, Guild of Guardians Leads Sales with $29.61 Million

    05/07/2025

    You Can Buy a Martian Meteorite With Bitcoin—If You Have Upwards of $4 Million

    04/07/2025

    Cheaper NFTs Mean Sales Are Surging, But Trading Volume is Plummeting: DappRadar

    04/07/2025

    Chimpers Expands Into NFT-Linked Blind Box Collectibles

    04/07/2025

    Tom Lee Says Ethereum Could Be the Next Bitcoin

    05/07/2025

    UK’s OpenTrade Raises $7M to Expand Stablecoin Yield Access in Inflation-Hit Markets

    05/07/2025

    Ripple Donates $25 Million Worth of RLUSD, Here’s Where It Is Going

    05/07/2025

    A Month Full of Achievements in Crypto Regulatory Sphere

    05/07/2025
  • Blockchain

    AGI Open Network Collaborates with Unmarshal to Incorporate Efficient AI Agents for Web3

    04/07/2025

    Circle Rolls Out Circle Gateway to Simplify USDC Cross‑Chain Use

    04/07/2025

    Zoro and AgentsGPT Partner to Advance the Future of Tokenized AI Agents

    04/07/2025

    Ice Open Network Teams Up with Uphold to Bridge Institutional Finance and Web3

    04/07/2025

    Kima Network Taps 8lends to Innovate Cross-Chain Decentralized Lending

    04/07/2025
  • DeFi

    ‘If I lose, DeFi dies with me:’ Tornado Cash co-founder doubles down on innocence ahead of trial

    05/07/2025

    Ethereum DeFi Project Ondo Aims to Take on Robinhood With Jump Into Tokenized Stocks

    05/07/2025

    Stablecoin banks like Erebor could inherit DeFi’s weakest links, says Web3 security firm

    04/07/2025

    Solana captures 95% of tokenized stock trading volume in massive DeFi pivot

    04/07/2025

    DeFi Enters New Era as Injective Debuts High-Speed Testnet Making it the Only L1 With Unified VM Layer

    04/07/2025
  • Metaverse

    Microsoft’s AI Diagnoses Like House, Bills Like Costco

    02/07/2025

    Mark Zuckerberg Unveils New Meta AI Lab After Poaching OpenAI Talent

    01/07/2025

    Can China’s MiniMax-M1 AI Topple US Rivals? We Put It to the Test

    28/06/2025

    Meta and OpenAI Use of Copyrighted Books for Training AI Was Fair Use: Federal Judge

    26/06/2025

    How to Get Your Chatbot to Talk Dirty

    18/06/2025
  • Regulation

    UK’s OpenTrade Raises $7M to Expand Stablecoin Yield Access in Inflation-Hit Markets

    05/07/2025

    “Bitcoin Doesn’t Need the US, the US Needs Bitcoin” – Here’s Why

    05/07/2025

    Why MARA Stock Could Outperform Bitcoin in This Bull Market

    05/07/2025

    Fitness Firm Interactive Strength Plans to Raise Up to $500M to Buy Fetch.AI’s FET Tokens

    05/07/2025

    Bitcoin Holder GameStop Gets an ETF From Bitwise

    05/07/2025
  • Other
    1. Exchanges
    2. ICO
    3. GameFi
    4. Mining
    5. Legal
    6. View All

    CoinDCX Delists Major Pairs, Indian Crypto Community Erupts

    05/07/2025

    KB Kookmin Card’s Pivotal Leap in Digital Currency Innovation

    05/07/2025

    Gate Alpha’s Points Carnival Changes How Crypto Users Access Airdrops

    05/07/2025

    BabyDoge Lists on Kraken Pro for Perpetual Futures Trading: Which CEX Next?

    05/07/2025

    ICO for bitcoin yield farming chain Corn screams we’re so back

    22/01/2025

    Why 2025 Will See the Comeback of the ICO

    26/12/2024

    Neural Expands to Solana with AI Game Creation Tools and Multi-Chain Support

    05/07/2025

    HeLa Space and Onmi Upgrade AR Gaming Experience with Web3 Adventure

    04/07/2025

    WizoLayer Partners with KingdomStarter to Revolutionize Web3 Gaming and DeFi

    04/07/2025

    PlayZap Games Joins Forces with DeFi Cattos to Offer Cutting-Edge Gaming via Aptos

    04/07/2025

    Another Solo Bitcoin Miner Beats the Odds, Winning $350K Jackpot

    05/07/2025

    World Famous E-Sports Giant Announces It Will Enter Bitcoin Mining Industry! Here Are the Details

    05/07/2025

    President Putin blames energy deficits for the creeping ban on crypto mining across Russia

    05/07/2025

    Esports Giant Ninjas in Pyjamas Buys Bitcoin Miners, Expects Monthly Production of $6.5M in BTC

    04/07/2025

    A Month Full of Achievements in Crypto Regulatory Sphere

    05/07/2025

    SEC must balance crypto innovation with enforcement

    05/07/2025

    How the US and Swiss Approaches Differ

    05/07/2025

    New Bills in South Korea Propose Capital Requirements for Stablecoin Issuers

    05/07/2025

    Tom Lee Says Ethereum Could Be the Next Bitcoin

    05/07/2025

    UK’s OpenTrade Raises $7M to Expand Stablecoin Yield Access in Inflation-Hit Markets

    05/07/2025

    Ripple Donates $25 Million Worth of RLUSD, Here’s Where It Is Going

    05/07/2025

    A Month Full of Achievements in Crypto Regulatory Sphere

    05/07/2025
  • MarketCap
NBTC News
Home»Legal»Why Tornado Cash Co-Founder Roman Storm’s Free Speech Defense Was Rejected in Court
Legal

Why Tornado Cash Co-Founder Roman Storm’s Free Speech Defense Was Rejected in Court

NBTCBy NBTC02/10/2024No Comments5 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


Code is protected speech? Not so fast, a U.S. district judge ruled last week in the high-profile case around Ethereum coin mixer Tornado Cash.

Judge Katherine Polk Failla rejected developer Roman Storm’s motion to dismiss his case in the Southern District of New York last Thursday. Over a year after the Tornado Cash co-founder was arrested on money-laundering charges, Failla ruled that his case could proceed to trial.

While Failla found that Storm had been adequately charged, Storm argued in his motion to dismiss that his charges infringed on his First Amendment rights. He stated it has been “well established” that computer code, such as a coin-mixing service, is protected speech.

“This prosecution represents an unprecedented attempt to criminalize the development of software,” Storm argued in his shot-down motion, adding that “the protections of the First Amendment apply to computer code, and computer programs constructed from code.”

When the United States sanctioned Tornado Cash in August 2022, banning the tool for masking Ethereum transactions and thus making them more difficult to track, the decision was decried by privacy advocates like Edward Snowden. The whistleblower warned the move was “deeply illiberal and profoundly authoritarian.”

The government has underscored Tornado Cash’s use by state-sponsored hackers as a threat, while crypto advocates have rallied around Storm’s cause. However, Failla’s ruling for industry-wide concerns boiled down to the statutes under which Storm was charged.

“These laws do not target protected expressive conduct,” Failla said of the laws Storm allegedly violated in launching and maintaining Tornado Cash. “They punish money laundering, […] the operation of an unlicensed money transmitting business, and […] sanctions evasion.”

David Miller, a partner at Greenberg Traurig and formerly an assistant U.S. attorney in the Southern District of New York, told Decrypt that Failla’s rejection shouldn’t be a surprise. Only under narrow circumstances are charges dismissed against an indictment, he said.

“The court ruled that using computer code to further alleged money laundering is not a First Amendment-protected activity,” he said. “This comes in the context of a motion to dismiss an indictment, and those are rarely granted in criminal cases.”

Functional vs. expressive

The First Amendment and coders have collided before. Members of the cypherpunk movement, from which Bitcoin was inspired, once advocated for cryptography in the name of free speech.

In an early internet era, Blockstream CEO Adam Back’s so-called “Munitions T-Shirt” emerged as a symbol of civil disobedience, featuring lines of code once deemed dangerous by the U.S. Others tattooed cryptography falling under government scrutiny directly onto their own skin.

As Failla noted, there are instances when code is being used to express a thought or idea. However, the functional capacity of code is not protected under the First Amendment, she said. As a result, the charges brought against Storm do not implicate free speech protections at all.

Miller said that Storm’s argument is reminiscent of free speech arguments made in material support of terrorism cases, which have been “universally rejected by courts.” That’s because the speech was in furtherance of a criminal objective, he added.

“As a general matter, it is difficult for criminal defendants to raise a First Amendment defense to an indictment,” Miller said. “The reason for that is because the criminal charges themselves are predicated upon conduct that violates federal criminal law, meaning the conduct is not criminalized because of the speech.”

Even if Storm’s actions were considered speech, a legal test known as “intermediate scrutiny” would’ve been satisfied, Failla said. Because the laws under which Storm was charged do not look to specifically regulate speech, prosecutors would only have to show that the government has a “substantial interest” in its restriction for the charges to be considered constitutional.

“The government has a substantial interest in promoting a secure financial system,” Failla said. “These interests are wholly unrelated to the suppression of free expression, and the applicability of these laws to Mr. Storm’s conduct does not burden substantially more speech than necessary […] because the charged conduct implicates the functional rather than the expressive features.”

‘Writing privacy code’

Following Storm’s arrest last year, Snowden and others encouraged donations to aid the developer’s legal fight—a sum that has swelled to $595,000 in Ethereum on the crowdfunding protocol Juicebox. Advocates have argued, meanwhile, that privacy is not a crime.

During previous campaigns, millions of dollars more had been raised to support “the freedom to publish code without fear of government persecution,” according to organizers of the Defend Roman Storm. Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has also weighed in on the issue.

Earlier this year, Alexey Pertsev was sentenced to 64 months in prison by Dutch authorities, who found that the Tornado Cash developer laundered $1.2 billion in illicit assets. Still, the support for Storm and his legal troubles continues pouring in.

On Sunday, an individual donated 99.5 Ethereum worth $259,000 to the aforementioned Juicebox fund. An accompanying message said, “I hope someone will help me out when the government freezes my assets for writing privacy code.”

Yet Failla herself might disagree with the donor’s characterization.

“At this stage in the case, this court cannot simply accept Mr. Storm’s narrative that he is being prosecuted merely for writing code,” she said during last week’s decision, describing it as “an overstatement of what’s actually charged in the indictment.”

Despite Failla’s skepticism, Miller said that Storm’s attorney’s could still try to assert free speech arguments if the case goes to trial in early December. But whether Failla will permit those arguments in front of a jury is ultimately another matter, he said.

Edited by Andrew Hayward

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
NBTC

Related Posts

A Month Full of Achievements in Crypto Regulatory Sphere

05/07/2025

SEC must balance crypto innovation with enforcement

05/07/2025

How the US and Swiss Approaches Differ

05/07/2025

New Bills in South Korea Propose Capital Requirements for Stablecoin Issuers

05/07/2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Top Posts
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Your source for the serious news. This website is crafted specifically to for crazy and hot cryptonews. Visit our main page for more tons of news.

We're social. Connect with us:

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Top Insights

Tom Lee Says Ethereum Could Be the Next Bitcoin

05/07/2025

UK’s OpenTrade Raises $7M to Expand Stablecoin Yield Access in Inflation-Hit Markets

05/07/2025

Ripple Donates $25 Million Worth of RLUSD, Here’s Where It Is Going

05/07/2025
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.