Close Menu
  • Coins
    • Bitcoin
    • Ethereum
    • Altcoins
    • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • DeFi
  • Metaverse
  • Regulation
  • Other
    • Exchanges
    • ICO
    • GameFi
    • Mining
    • Legal
  • MarketCap
What's Hot

LasMeta and Pyth Network Partner to Unveil NovaDrop NFTs

26/07/2025

Ethereum Name Service (ENS) Skyrockets 16% as Ecosystem Developments Drive Demand

26/07/2025

If BTC Price Surpasses Here, He Will Overtake Warren Buffett

26/07/2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Back to NBTC homepage
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
X (Twitter) Telegram Facebook LinkedIn RSS
NBTC News
  • Coins
    1. Bitcoin
    2. Ethereum
    3. Altcoins
    4. NFT
    5. View All

    If BTC Price Surpasses Here, He Will Overtake Warren Buffett

    26/07/2025

    EV Firm Volcon Joins the Bitcoin Treasury Trend with $500M in Capital

    26/07/2025

    Will Bitcoin Treasury Companies Kickstart the Next Crypto Bear Market?

    26/07/2025

    Matador Aims to Buy 6,000 BTC, Eyes Top 20 Spot by 2027

    26/07/2025

    Ethereum Is So Back? ETH Price Jumps to 2025 High Amid Open Interest Surge

    25/07/2025

    ‘Ethereum Avengers’ Firm to Generate ETH Using $1.5 Billion Stockpile

    25/07/2025

    Cathie Wood’s ARK Loads Up on Ether Treasury Bet Bitmine Immersion

    25/07/2025

    Ethereum Has Already Won—Paul Brody

    25/07/2025

    Ethereum Name Service (ENS) Skyrockets 16% as Ecosystem Developments Drive Demand

    26/07/2025

    WeChat Froggie Mascot Spikes a Meme Coin Rally

    26/07/2025

    A Phenomenal 44% Surge for Solana’s AI-Powered Health Crypto

    26/07/2025

    Wall Street, Walmart & Web3

    26/07/2025

    LasMeta and Pyth Network Partner to Unveil NovaDrop NFTs

    26/07/2025

    Ripple CTO regrets the time he censored Ozzy Osbourne

    26/07/2025

    NFT market cap surged to $6.6B in July: DappRadar

    25/07/2025

    Ethereum Treasury Firm Buys $5M CryptoPunk—And Is Borrowing Stablecoins Against It

    25/07/2025

    LasMeta and Pyth Network Partner to Unveil NovaDrop NFTs

    26/07/2025

    Ethereum Name Service (ENS) Skyrockets 16% as Ecosystem Developments Drive Demand

    26/07/2025

    If BTC Price Surpasses Here, He Will Overtake Warren Buffett

    26/07/2025

    WeChat Froggie Mascot Spikes a Meme Coin Rally

    26/07/2025
  • Blockchain

    A Game-Changer for Network Efficiency

    26/07/2025

    Is Ripple Powering BlackRock’s $100 Trillion Blockchain Vision?

    26/07/2025

    Zircuit Introduces Cross-Chain AI Trading with Hyperliquid Engine

    26/07/2025

    Sahara Labs Unveils Data Services Planform to Revolutionize AI Training

    26/07/2025

    Bridges are a road to nowhere for blockchain communications

    26/07/2025
  • DeFi

    Apple Farm season 2 now live on Etherlink with $3M in rewards

    25/07/2025

    Retail XRP Holders Could Soon Earn 20% Yield on Their Tokens

    25/07/2025

    Pell Network Collaborates with HashKey Chain to Forge BTCFi Revolution in RWA Sector

    25/07/2025

    Revolutionary Injective Tokenization Unlocks $1.3B ETH Treasury for DeFi

    25/07/2025

    Deciding the Future of Reimbursement After the Exploit

    25/07/2025
  • Metaverse

    AntVerse Integrates Terminus to Transform AI-Powered Metaverse with Web3 Payments

    25/07/2025

    The Sandbox Launches Largest LAND Auction Using GBM Protocol

    21/07/2025

    Elon Musk’s xAI Quietly Fixed Grok by Deleting a Line of Code

    09/07/2025

    Bonk.fun Grabs 55% of Solana Token Issuance Share, Pushes BONK Demand

    08/07/2025

    Apple’s Top AI Exec Leaves For Meta Amid Aggressive Hiring Trend

    08/07/2025
  • Regulation

    U.S. June CPI Rose an In Line 0.3%; Core Rate Slightly Better Than Hoped at 0.2%

    26/07/2025

    BREAKING! US Inflation Data Released! Here’s Bitcoin (BTC)’s First Reaction!

    26/07/2025

    How Was the First Half of 2025? Institutional and Individual Investors Followed Different Strategies! “Institutions Flocked to Bitcoin and Ethereum, While Individual Investors Flocked…

    26/07/2025

    Donald Trump Launches Official Process for Fed Chair! US Treasury Secretary Calls for “Extension” to Powell!

    26/07/2025

    Here’s why the stock and crypto markets rose after the US inflation data

    26/07/2025
  • Other
    1. Exchanges
    2. ICO
    3. GameFi
    4. Mining
    5. Legal
    6. View All

    Kraken to Support Biotech Firm Windtree’s $200M BNB Treasury Play

    25/07/2025

    Bahamas Claims Approved, US Hearing Underway

    25/07/2025

    EDX Unveils International Crypto Trading Platform With Perpetual Futures

    25/07/2025

    CoinDCX CEO Counters $44.2M Hack Fears Revealing $136 Million in Annual Revenue

    25/07/2025

    ICO for bitcoin yield farming chain Corn screams we’re so back

    22/01/2025

    Why 2025 Will See the Comeback of the ICO

    26/12/2024

    Octo Gaming Teams Up with Starknet for Exclusive Rollup-Powered Game Launch

    25/07/2025

    Off the Grid Skin Sale Volume Hits $30K as the Avalanche Shooter Hits OpenSea

    25/07/2025

    Axie Infinity Creator Sky Mavis Backs New BORA-Integrated Game on LINE NEXT App

    24/07/2025

    ‘Tokyo Beast’ Speedruns Crypto Game Cycle, Shutting Down Just a Month After Launch

    24/07/2025

    Tether’s Mining OS Set to Go Open Source by End-of-Year, Confirms Paolo Ardoino

    26/07/2025

    Bitmain Funnels 187 Tons of Antminer Parts to Skirt US Tariffs

    25/07/2025

    Russian authorities implicate illegal mining for 200% spike in video card sales

    25/07/2025

    ‘Every family here is sick,‘ say neighbors of Bitcoin mining facility in Texas

    25/07/2025

    Hong Kong’s stablecoin licensing to adopt invite-only approach: report

    25/07/2025

    Senator Warren Slams GOP’s Crypto Plan, Warns of ‘Presidential Corruption’

    25/07/2025

    White House Set to Launch First Major Crypto Policy Report On July 22

    25/07/2025

    SEC explores Ethereum token standard for compliant securities

    25/07/2025

    LasMeta and Pyth Network Partner to Unveil NovaDrop NFTs

    26/07/2025

    Ethereum Name Service (ENS) Skyrockets 16% as Ecosystem Developments Drive Demand

    26/07/2025

    If BTC Price Surpasses Here, He Will Overtake Warren Buffett

    26/07/2025

    WeChat Froggie Mascot Spikes a Meme Coin Rally

    26/07/2025
  • MarketCap
NBTC News
Home»Legal»Why Tornado Cash Co-Founder Roman Storm’s Free Speech Defense Was Rejected in Court
Legal

Why Tornado Cash Co-Founder Roman Storm’s Free Speech Defense Was Rejected in Court

NBTCBy NBTC02/10/2024No Comments5 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


Code is protected speech? Not so fast, a U.S. district judge ruled last week in the high-profile case around Ethereum coin mixer Tornado Cash.

Judge Katherine Polk Failla rejected developer Roman Storm’s motion to dismiss his case in the Southern District of New York last Thursday. Over a year after the Tornado Cash co-founder was arrested on money-laundering charges, Failla ruled that his case could proceed to trial.

While Failla found that Storm had been adequately charged, Storm argued in his motion to dismiss that his charges infringed on his First Amendment rights. He stated it has been “well established” that computer code, such as a coin-mixing service, is protected speech.

“This prosecution represents an unprecedented attempt to criminalize the development of software,” Storm argued in his shot-down motion, adding that “the protections of the First Amendment apply to computer code, and computer programs constructed from code.”

When the United States sanctioned Tornado Cash in August 2022, banning the tool for masking Ethereum transactions and thus making them more difficult to track, the decision was decried by privacy advocates like Edward Snowden. The whistleblower warned the move was “deeply illiberal and profoundly authoritarian.”

The government has underscored Tornado Cash’s use by state-sponsored hackers as a threat, while crypto advocates have rallied around Storm’s cause. However, Failla’s ruling for industry-wide concerns boiled down to the statutes under which Storm was charged.

“These laws do not target protected expressive conduct,” Failla said of the laws Storm allegedly violated in launching and maintaining Tornado Cash. “They punish money laundering, […] the operation of an unlicensed money transmitting business, and […] sanctions evasion.”

David Miller, a partner at Greenberg Traurig and formerly an assistant U.S. attorney in the Southern District of New York, told Decrypt that Failla’s rejection shouldn’t be a surprise. Only under narrow circumstances are charges dismissed against an indictment, he said.

“The court ruled that using computer code to further alleged money laundering is not a First Amendment-protected activity,” he said. “This comes in the context of a motion to dismiss an indictment, and those are rarely granted in criminal cases.”

Functional vs. expressive

The First Amendment and coders have collided before. Members of the cypherpunk movement, from which Bitcoin was inspired, once advocated for cryptography in the name of free speech.

In an early internet era, Blockstream CEO Adam Back’s so-called “Munitions T-Shirt” emerged as a symbol of civil disobedience, featuring lines of code once deemed dangerous by the U.S. Others tattooed cryptography falling under government scrutiny directly onto their own skin.

As Failla noted, there are instances when code is being used to express a thought or idea. However, the functional capacity of code is not protected under the First Amendment, she said. As a result, the charges brought against Storm do not implicate free speech protections at all.

Miller said that Storm’s argument is reminiscent of free speech arguments made in material support of terrorism cases, which have been “universally rejected by courts.” That’s because the speech was in furtherance of a criminal objective, he added.

“As a general matter, it is difficult for criminal defendants to raise a First Amendment defense to an indictment,” Miller said. “The reason for that is because the criminal charges themselves are predicated upon conduct that violates federal criminal law, meaning the conduct is not criminalized because of the speech.”

Even if Storm’s actions were considered speech, a legal test known as “intermediate scrutiny” would’ve been satisfied, Failla said. Because the laws under which Storm was charged do not look to specifically regulate speech, prosecutors would only have to show that the government has a “substantial interest” in its restriction for the charges to be considered constitutional.

“The government has a substantial interest in promoting a secure financial system,” Failla said. “These interests are wholly unrelated to the suppression of free expression, and the applicability of these laws to Mr. Storm’s conduct does not burden substantially more speech than necessary […] because the charged conduct implicates the functional rather than the expressive features.”

‘Writing privacy code’

Following Storm’s arrest last year, Snowden and others encouraged donations to aid the developer’s legal fight—a sum that has swelled to $595,000 in Ethereum on the crowdfunding protocol Juicebox. Advocates have argued, meanwhile, that privacy is not a crime.

During previous campaigns, millions of dollars more had been raised to support “the freedom to publish code without fear of government persecution,” according to organizers of the Defend Roman Storm. Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has also weighed in on the issue.

Earlier this year, Alexey Pertsev was sentenced to 64 months in prison by Dutch authorities, who found that the Tornado Cash developer laundered $1.2 billion in illicit assets. Still, the support for Storm and his legal troubles continues pouring in.

On Sunday, an individual donated 99.5 Ethereum worth $259,000 to the aforementioned Juicebox fund. An accompanying message said, “I hope someone will help me out when the government freezes my assets for writing privacy code.”

Yet Failla herself might disagree with the donor’s characterization.

“At this stage in the case, this court cannot simply accept Mr. Storm’s narrative that he is being prosecuted merely for writing code,” she said during last week’s decision, describing it as “an overstatement of what’s actually charged in the indictment.”

Despite Failla’s skepticism, Miller said that Storm’s attorney’s could still try to assert free speech arguments if the case goes to trial in early December. But whether Failla will permit those arguments in front of a jury is ultimately another matter, he said.

Edited by Andrew Hayward

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
NBTC

Related Posts

Hong Kong’s stablecoin licensing to adopt invite-only approach: report

25/07/2025

Senator Warren Slams GOP’s Crypto Plan, Warns of ‘Presidential Corruption’

25/07/2025

White House Set to Launch First Major Crypto Policy Report On July 22

25/07/2025

SEC explores Ethereum token standard for compliant securities

25/07/2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Top Posts
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Your source for the serious news. This website is crafted specifically to for crazy and hot cryptonews. Visit our main page for more tons of news.

We're social. Connect with us:

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Top Insights

LasMeta and Pyth Network Partner to Unveil NovaDrop NFTs

26/07/2025

Ethereum Name Service (ENS) Skyrockets 16% as Ecosystem Developments Drive Demand

26/07/2025

If BTC Price Surpasses Here, He Will Overtake Warren Buffett

26/07/2025
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.