Close Menu
  • Coins
    • Bitcoin
    • Ethereum
    • Altcoins
    • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • DeFi
  • Metaverse
  • Regulation
  • Other
    • Exchanges
    • ICO
    • GameFi
    • Mining
    • Legal
  • MarketCap
What's Hot

Unprecedented 29.26% of ETH Supply Staked

13/07/2025

Israel Will Buy BTC and ETH and Give it to a Gambling Offender

13/07/2025

AP Token Price Explodes as Elon Musk Unveils America Party Plans

13/07/2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Back to NBTC homepage
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
X (Twitter) Telegram Facebook LinkedIn RSS
NBTC News
  • Coins
    1. Bitcoin
    2. Ethereum
    3. Altcoins
    4. NFT
    5. View All

    Bitcoin Long-Term Holders Data Hint When the Next All-Time High Might Be

    13/07/2025

    Bitcoin reclaims $109K after Trump pushes back 50% EU tariff deadline

    13/07/2025

    staking, liquid staking tokens and vaulted strategies

    13/07/2025

    Rich Dad Poor Dad Author Can’t Believe People Aren’t Buying Bitcoin

    13/07/2025

    Unprecedented 29.26% of ETH Supply Staked

    13/07/2025

    Joseph Lubin on His Ecosystem

    13/07/2025

    Crypto Investor Ryan Sean Adams Calls Ethereum the Next World Reserve Asset

    13/07/2025

    Ethereum to $3,000, 21Shares Makes Case for ETH Price Breakout

    13/07/2025

    AP Token Price Explodes as Elon Musk Unveils America Party Plans

    13/07/2025

    Filecoin and Akave Cloud Unlock Next-Gen Data Storage Power

    13/07/2025

    Analytics Firm CEO Says “Follow the Whales for Price”, Reveals Four Altcoins That Whales Are Heavily Long on!

    13/07/2025

    Here’s the Mysterious XRP Ledger Co-Founder Who Holds 2% of All XRP

    13/07/2025

    Volume Plunges While Transactions Soar

    11/07/2025

    Snoop Dogg’s TON NFT Launch Could Signal New Narrative for NFT Market

    10/07/2025

    Snoop Dogg’s Telegram NFT Drop Sold Out in Half an Hour

    10/07/2025

    Why a ‘Mobile-First’ Mentality Drove OpenSea’s Latest Acquisition

    09/07/2025

    Unprecedented 29.26% of ETH Supply Staked

    13/07/2025

    Israel Will Buy BTC and ETH and Give it to a Gambling Offender

    13/07/2025

    AP Token Price Explodes as Elon Musk Unveils America Party Plans

    13/07/2025

    Q3 Bitcoin Mining Map Exposes Silent Surge in Russia, China, While US Dips Slightly

    13/07/2025
  • Blockchain

    Bullish is migrating its entire trading, custody, and settlement infrastructure to Solana

    13/07/2025

    Stability World AI Joins Forces with BearFAI to Revolutionize AI Utility Across Web3

    13/07/2025

    Logic Meets Modularity in this Big Partnership

    13/07/2025

    Band Protocol Unveils V3, A New Era of Multichain and Lightning-fast Data for Web3

    13/07/2025

    All Franklin Templeton products will one day be onchain, exec says

    12/07/2025
  • DeFi

    Nasdaq-Listed Firm Secures $200M in Financing, with Over $150M Tied to Solana Treasury Strategy

    12/07/2025

    TaskOn Partners DEXTools to Bolster Web3 Community Participation

    12/07/2025

    InceptionLRT is shutting down just six months after raising $3.5 million in seed funding

    12/07/2025

    Aave gains 18% weekly amid ecosystem growth, stablecoin dominance

    12/07/2025

    Plume Launches SkyLink on TRON to Enable Real-World Asset Yields

    11/07/2025
  • Metaverse

    Elon Musk’s xAI Quietly Fixed Grok by Deleting a Line of Code

    09/07/2025

    Bonk.fun Grabs 55% of Solana Token Issuance Share, Pushes BONK Demand

    08/07/2025

    Apple’s Top AI Exec Leaves For Meta Amid Aggressive Hiring Trend

    08/07/2025

    Automobili Lamborghini Unveils Digital Temerario and GT3 NFTs in Wilder World

    07/07/2025

    Microsoft’s AI Diagnoses Like House, Bills Like Costco

    02/07/2025
  • Regulation

    Israel Will Buy BTC and ETH and Give it to a Gambling Offender

    13/07/2025

    Coinbase CEO Reacts to Major Crypto Institutional Milestone: Details

    13/07/2025

    KraneShares Unveils Pioneering Opportunity for Digital Asset Investors

    13/07/2025

    One of the Largest Cryptocurrency Banks in the US Has Asked Its Customers to Sell Three Cryptocurrencies, Sparking Controversy

    13/07/2025

    RWA Market Caps $24B With 85% YoY Growth as Tokenization Goes Mainstream

    13/07/2025
  • Other
    1. Exchanges
    2. ICO
    3. GameFi
    4. Mining
    5. Legal
    6. View All

    Coinbase Lists 4 New Cryptocurrencies After Securing License in New York

    12/07/2025

    Cumberland Unveils Massive 13,100 ETH Withdrawal from Binance

    12/07/2025

    Robinhood Says OpenAI Stock Tokens Backed by Special Purpose Vehicle

    12/07/2025

    Aevo unveils platform offering 1000x leverage on select stocks like MSTR and CRCL

    12/07/2025

    ICO for bitcoin yield farming chain Corn screams we’re so back

    22/01/2025

    Why 2025 Will See the Comeback of the ICO

    26/12/2024

    Why Are So Many Crypto Games Shutting Down? Experts Weigh In

    12/07/2025

    The Real Lifestyle and WILDGO Partner to Transform Tokenized Real Estate

    12/07/2025

    Blazpay and Onmi AR Unite to Elevate Web3 Gaming Experience

    10/07/2025

    Floki’s Valhalla Surpasses 100K Veras Minted Within Days of Launch

    09/07/2025

    Q3 Bitcoin Mining Map Exposes Silent Surge in Russia, China, While US Dips Slightly

    13/07/2025

    Another BTC Mining Firm Moves Into Ethereum Reserve, Hailing ETH as ‘Digital Gold’

    13/07/2025

    CKpool rolls out low-latency pool after solo miner racks up 3.175 BTC reward

    13/07/2025

    CoreWeave Fusion Dance, $1 Billion Day for Bitcoin ETFs and Strategy’s Bye Week

    12/07/2025

    Crypto traders ‘talking to lawyers’ over Polymarket’s Zelenskyy suit bet

    12/07/2025

    US Senate targets Bukele’s El Salvador, bill calls to sanction BTC strategy

    12/07/2025

    Tornado Cash Judge Won’t Let One Case Be Mentioned in Roman Storm’s Trial: Here’s Why

    12/07/2025

    Trump Ally Compares Crypto Industry Writing Its Own Rules to Spilled ‘Urine Sample’

    12/07/2025

    Unprecedented 29.26% of ETH Supply Staked

    13/07/2025

    Israel Will Buy BTC and ETH and Give it to a Gambling Offender

    13/07/2025

    AP Token Price Explodes as Elon Musk Unveils America Party Plans

    13/07/2025

    Q3 Bitcoin Mining Map Exposes Silent Surge in Russia, China, While US Dips Slightly

    13/07/2025
  • MarketCap
NBTC News
Home»Legal»FINRA’s intrusive crypto sweeps are misguided
Legal

FINRA’s intrusive crypto sweeps are misguided

NBTCBy NBTC11/03/2024No Comments6 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is continuing its bizarre transformation into a crypto asset regulator with the recent publication of its Crypto Assets Communications Sweep (Sweep) results.

FINRA lacks regulatory authority over non-securities crypto assets. Despite this fact, FINRA continues to display an unwavering, albeit misguided interest in the non-securities crypto asset activities of its members, affiliates, vendors and personnel.

FINRA initiated the Sweep more than 14 months ago: It consumed significant time, resources and attention for those subjected to the Sweep. But even with the significant allocation of valuable member resources, the Sweep findings are lackluster at best, and at worst highlight FINRA’s continued struggle to make sense of a complex industry outside of its regulatory gambit.

While the Sweep reflects further intrusion into the non-securities crypto asset regulatory space by an unqualified regulator, the broader implications for current FINRA members and those hoping to achieve membership are strikingly discouraging.

Where does the Sweep come from?

FINRA debuted its foray into the non-securities crypto asset regulatory space in 2018 with the publication of Regulatory Notice 18-20 (RN 18-20).

This notice “encouraged” FINRA members to notify FINRA if the member, any of its affiliates or associated persons engaged or intended to engage in any activity related to crypto assets.

FINRA’s curiosity extended beyond crypto asset securities, and requested details regarding any and all manner of crypto asset activities. FINRA effectively re-issued this reporting request in Regulatory Notice 20-23 in 2020 and Regulatory Notice 21-25 in 2021, the latter of which remains in place to this day.

Not content with its far-reaching and blunt reporting “request,” FINRA then initiated a targeted exam of FINRA member retail communications concerning crypto asset products and services in November 2022.

Sweep findings

FINRA reviewed more than 500 crypto asset-retail communications, dedicated valuable FINRA resources and no doubt consumed countless FINRA member manhours in conducting the Sweep.

The result?

Opaque references to having identified “potential” violations of FINRA advertising rules.

The reality?

If our experience representing FINRA members subject to the Sweep is any indication, the Sweep appears to have effectively served as an out-sourced, self-serving educational program of sorts, paid for and imposed on FINRA members by regulatory fiat.

Read more from our opinion section: Washington shouldn’t give in to crypto panic

The Sweep found, among other things, FINRA member communications that included “unclear and misleading explanations of how crypto assets work and their core features and risks” as well as “comparisons of crypto assets to other assets […] without providing a basis to compare the varying features and risks of these investments.”

Unfortunately, these “findings” raise more questions than answers.

For instance, by what standard does FINRA possibly determine whether the core features and risks of a non-securities crypto asset product is appropriately explained? Most non-securities crypto asset products are regulated by the states and/or the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and facilitated by appropriately (and separately) regulated FINRA member affiliates. To what extent are FINRA members expected to conform their affiliate marketing to satisfy the uninformed views of a securities regulator as to the operation of a non-securities, separately regulated financial product?

Put bluntly, does FINRA have the capacity to know whether a non-securities crypto asset is in fact accurately explained, or the risks accurately presented?

The issue of cross-affiliate marketing is far from novel. In fact, many of the nation’s largest broker-dealers market securities products side-by-side with traditional and sophisticated non-securities financial products offered by their affiliates.

Does FINRA hold itself out as the arbiter for determining whether precious metal futures or indexed universal life insurance products are “unclear and misleading” over the judgment (and regulatory oversight) of the company’s expert in such products? We suspect not.

Implications for the securities industry

FINRA’s seeming compulsion to insert itself in matters further and further afield from its regulatory mandate presents real-world consequences for both operating broker-dealers as well as those companies looking to establish securities firms.

For operating broker-dealers, they are increasingly required to dedicate time and resources to navigate intrusive and often non-sensical FINRA crypto asset regulatory inquiries. These inquiries are often focused on products or services that are not even offered by the FINRA member itself.

This state of affairs places unnecessary burdens on internal compliance teams, hinders product development and obfuscates the separate and well-established regulatory regimes within which many broker-dealers and their affiliates operate.

For crypto asset companies intending to establish separate, FINRA member broker-dealers, FINRA’s preoccupation with non-securities crypto assets has expanded in scope. What was once simply a nuisance is now a fundamental misalignment of regulatory functions and priorities that often effectively serves to prohibit new member applicants with crypto asset affiliates from obtaining membership.

As an example, we have seen firsthand FINRA’s Membership Application Program Group (MAP) import the Sweep examination criteria directly into the new membership process. This action fundamentally and improperly re-characterizes the MAP function from one of membership evaluation to exam enforcement. MAP is not equipped to serve this function, nor should it be. Unfortunately, innovative, tech-focused investment platforms continue to bear the brunt of FINRA’s continued imprudence in this respect.

Until FINRA abandons its misguided attempt to seek indirect oversight over non-securities crypto assets and the activities of separately regulated financial institutions, market integrity and the investing public will undoubtedly continue to suffer.


Ethan L. Silver is Chair of the FinTech and Broker-Dealer Practices and Co-Chair of the crypto practice at law firm Lowenstein Sandler. Ethan is a recognized leader in the representation of broker-dealers in regulatory, enforcement, and compliance matters related to federal and state securities laws and regulations; and the rules of self-regulatory organizations such as Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). He also spearheads the firm’s crypto and FinTech practices, representing wide-ranging crypto-focused businesses and regulated financial technology companies including mobile-first brokerage platforms and digital-advisers.

William Brannan is a partner and Vice Chair of Lowenstein Sandler’s crypto practice. He provides counsel regulated financial technology companies navigating complex securities, derivatives, and cryptocurrency regulatory issues. Will regularly advises digital asset exchanges, multi-asset trading platforms, robo-advisers, market makers, liquidity providers, custodians and digital asset services providers with respect to federal and state cryptocurrency regulations, securities laws, FINRA rules, security-based swap rules, state money transmitter licensing requirements and the New York BitLicense.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
NBTC

Related Posts

Crypto traders ‘talking to lawyers’ over Polymarket’s Zelenskyy suit bet

12/07/2025

US Senate targets Bukele’s El Salvador, bill calls to sanction BTC strategy

12/07/2025

Tornado Cash Judge Won’t Let One Case Be Mentioned in Roman Storm’s Trial: Here’s Why

12/07/2025

Trump Ally Compares Crypto Industry Writing Its Own Rules to Spilled ‘Urine Sample’

12/07/2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Top Posts
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Your source for the serious news. This website is crafted specifically to for crazy and hot cryptonews. Visit our main page for more tons of news.

We're social. Connect with us:

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Top Insights

Unprecedented 29.26% of ETH Supply Staked

13/07/2025

Israel Will Buy BTC and ETH and Give it to a Gambling Offender

13/07/2025

AP Token Price Explodes as Elon Musk Unveils America Party Plans

13/07/2025
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.