Close Menu
  • Coins
    • Bitcoin
    • Ethereum
    • Altcoins
    • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • DeFi
  • Metaverse
  • Regulation
  • Other
    • Exchanges
    • ICO
    • GameFi
    • Mining
    • Legal
  • MarketCap
What's Hot

Kana Labs and Rewardy Wallet Unveil Multi-Chain Swap Experience with Version 1.4.0

18/07/2025

BitMine Immersion Surges 40% After Revealing $500M ETH Treasury

18/07/2025

David Sacks Backs Trump’s GENIUS Act Push to Make US Undisputed Crypto Leader

18/07/2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Back to NBTC homepage
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
X (Twitter) Telegram Facebook LinkedIn RSS
NBTC News
  • Coins
    1. Bitcoin
    2. Ethereum
    3. Altcoins
    4. NFT
    5. View All

    Bitcoin celebrates Pizza Day with price record, Hall of Fame induction

    18/07/2025

    Satoshi-Era BTC on Move, On-chain Data Finds

    18/07/2025

    Méliuz Plans Massive $26.5M Bitcoin Purchase Boost

    18/07/2025

    Bitcoin Liquid Network Surpasses $3.27 Billion in Total Value Locked

    18/07/2025

    BitMine Immersion Surges 40% After Revealing $500M ETH Treasury

    18/07/2025

    Ultra-Rare Ethereum (ETH) Price Signal Appears: Details

    18/07/2025

    Ethereum Has Torched $13.5B in ETH — But the Supply Keeps Growing

    18/07/2025

    AI sets date when Ethereum will trade at $4,000

    18/07/2025

    1,000,000 Solana in One Minute, SOL Whale Activated

    18/07/2025

    Shiba Inu Lead Confirms Revenue Trumps Utility in Crypto Success, Teases Strategic Plan Reveal

    18/07/2025

    Pundit Says Sleep on XRP and You Will Miss the Greatest Wealth Transfer in History

    18/07/2025

    Investment Giant JPMorgan Approaches Stablecoin Market Cautiously! Here Are 2028 Predictions

    18/07/2025

    CryptoPunks Dominate Top Weekly NFT Sales amid Overall Market Sales Volume Surges 34.19% to $133.66 Million

    14/07/2025

    Volume Plunges While Transactions Soar

    11/07/2025

    Snoop Dogg’s TON NFT Launch Could Signal New Narrative for NFT Market

    10/07/2025

    Snoop Dogg’s Telegram NFT Drop Sold Out in Half an Hour

    10/07/2025

    Kana Labs and Rewardy Wallet Unveil Multi-Chain Swap Experience with Version 1.4.0

    18/07/2025

    BitMine Immersion Surges 40% After Revealing $500M ETH Treasury

    18/07/2025

    David Sacks Backs Trump’s GENIUS Act Push to Make US Undisputed Crypto Leader

    18/07/2025

    CARV Joins Anomaly Games to Redefine AI-Led Gaming Interoperability

    18/07/2025
  • Blockchain

    PayPal Blockchain Lead José Fernández da Ponte Joins Stellar

    18/07/2025

    Risc Zero’s ‘Boundless’ Incentivized Testnet Goes Live

    18/07/2025

    Base rebrands as Basechain and unveils Flashblocks, Base app, and dev tools in major overhaul

    18/07/2025

    Anoma Launches Testnet to Unify Web3 with Intent-Centric OS

    18/07/2025

    Binance Launches $1M Blockchain Education Initiative the Digital Future of Vietnam

    18/07/2025
  • DeFi

    Kana Labs and Rewardy Wallet Unveil Multi-Chain Swap Experience with Version 1.4.0

    18/07/2025

    StakeStone Unlocks New Era of DeFi with USD1 Vault

    18/07/2025

    Lombard Finance Reveals Tools for Native BTC Access on Any Chain

    18/07/2025

    Bitlayer’s BitVM Bridge Revolutionizes BTC Integration

    17/07/2025

    Ushering In a New Era on Solana

    17/07/2025
  • Metaverse

    Elon Musk’s xAI Quietly Fixed Grok by Deleting a Line of Code

    09/07/2025

    Bonk.fun Grabs 55% of Solana Token Issuance Share, Pushes BONK Demand

    08/07/2025

    Apple’s Top AI Exec Leaves For Meta Amid Aggressive Hiring Trend

    08/07/2025

    Automobili Lamborghini Unveils Digital Temerario and GT3 NFTs in Wilder World

    07/07/2025

    Microsoft’s AI Diagnoses Like House, Bills Like Costco

    02/07/2025
  • Regulation

    More than half of Russia’s ‘qualified investors’ now have crypto stakes

    18/07/2025

    Much Anticipated FED Minutes Have Been Released – Here Are All the Details

    18/07/2025

    Bitcoin Treasury Firm Thumzup Considering Dogecoin, XRP Buys as Trump Jr. Invests

    18/07/2025

    Trump Imposes Surprising 50% Tariff on Brazil as Crypto Market Reacts

    18/07/2025

    The first $4T company

    18/07/2025
  • Other
    1. Exchanges
    2. ICO
    3. GameFi
    4. Mining
    5. Legal
    6. View All

    15% drop and doubts about transparency

    18/07/2025

    Binance’s Biggest Milestones in Eight Years Teased by Richard Teng, Community Reacts

    18/07/2025

    GroveX Introduces Credit Card Crypto Buying Feature to Streamline Digital Asset Access

    18/07/2025

    Nobody knows why HTX is juggling $1B USDT on Aave •

    18/07/2025

    ICO for bitcoin yield farming chain Corn screams we’re so back

    22/01/2025

    Why 2025 Will See the Comeback of the ICO

    26/12/2024

    CARV Joins Anomaly Games to Redefine AI-Led Gaming Interoperability

    18/07/2025

    GaFin Joins Efforts with Helium Wars to Redefine the Future of Web3 Gaming

    16/07/2025

    Crypto games are struggling in 2025, but big brands aren’t giving up

    15/07/2025

    R-Games and LoveBit Unite to Power ESG-Driven Web3 Gaming

    15/07/2025

    U.S.-Listed Bitcoin Miners Reach New Peak Share of Global Hashrate

    17/07/2025

    French lawmakers say country could generate $150M in annual revenue from Bitcoin mining

    17/07/2025

    Bitcoin Mempool Emptiness Sparks Network Security Concerns

    16/07/2025

    All-Time High Mining Difficulty, Quiet Google Trends—Is This the ‘Mature’ Bitcoin Bull Market?

    15/07/2025

    David Sacks Backs Trump’s GENIUS Act Push to Make US Undisputed Crypto Leader

    18/07/2025

    SEC commissioner removes head of the PCAOB

    18/07/2025

    New Reports That Donald Trump May Fire Fed Chairman Jerome Powell – They Held a Meeting Yesterday

    18/07/2025

    Fidelity Urges Congress to Fix Bitcoin and Crypto Tax Rules as Lawmakers Push New Regulations

    18/07/2025

    Kana Labs and Rewardy Wallet Unveil Multi-Chain Swap Experience with Version 1.4.0

    18/07/2025

    BitMine Immersion Surges 40% After Revealing $500M ETH Treasury

    18/07/2025

    David Sacks Backs Trump’s GENIUS Act Push to Make US Undisputed Crypto Leader

    18/07/2025

    CARV Joins Anomaly Games to Redefine AI-Led Gaming Interoperability

    18/07/2025
  • MarketCap
NBTC News
Home»Legal»Ending the Treasury Department’s Regulatory Overreach on Crypto Mixer Tornado Cash
Legal

Ending the Treasury Department’s Regulatory Overreach on Crypto Mixer Tornado Cash

NBTCBy NBTC10/12/2024No Comments5 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


Cryptocurrency users who crave privacy protections had a lot to be thankful for this past Thanksgiving.

Two days before the holiday, a unanimous three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit ruled that the Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) had acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner not supported by substantial evidence when it “overstepped its congressionally defined authority” in sanctioning “Tornado Cash’s open-source, self-executing software” instead of “the rogue persons and entities who abuse it.”

In plain English, Congress didn’t give OFAC the power to do what it did: sanction software code owned by no one.

But let’s back up. As I have explained for CoinDesk before, Tornado Cash is a crypto mixer that makes it tougher to trace cryptocurrency transactions. There are many legitimate and legal uses of such a service, but there are illegal uses too. For example, cyber criminals and hostile state actors have used Tornado Cash and other services to shield their nefarious acts.

Because of the latter actions, OFAC added many Tornado Cash addresses to its Specifically Designated National and Blocked Persons (SDN) list.

But under the relevant statutory provisions, Congress gave OFAC only the power to sanction the property, including any interest in the property, of certain people.

And here, the court, in an opinion written by Judge Don Willett, said that the immutable smart contracts at issue didn’t constitute property, so OFAC couldn’t sanction them.

The court said “because that element is dispositive, [it] need not address the other elements” at issue in the case. It said that the “district court erred in giving ‘heightened deference’ to OFAC’s definition of ‘property’ and in finding that immutable smart contracts met that definition.”

Because of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Loper Bright decision from last term doing away with Chevron deference — the requirement that courts defer to agency interpretations of ambiguous statutory (or even regulatory!) provisions — the court said it was engaging in the “unremarkable, yet elemental proposition” of applying its own judgment to determine what a statute means.

Doing that, the court said that under both the plain meaning of property and under OFAC’s regulatory definition of property, the term means something that can be owned. And in this case, the immutable smart contracts at issue did not qualify as property because they cannot be owned.

The court went further, though, and made two points that might have implications for crypto and smart contracts more broadly.

First, the court said the immutable smart contracts at issue are not themselves contracts — despite their misleading name and contrary to what the district court held.

While the district court found the contracts to be “merely a code-enabled species of unilateral contracts,” the Fifth Circuit panel said that in “so finding, the district court ignored basic principles of black-letter contract law.” It explained that all contracts require at least two parties, but here, the immutable smart contracts “have only one party in play” because they are “just software code,” not a party who can contract with another party.

The Fifth Circuit made clear that its decision is not contrary to the “blockchain caselaw,” which indicates that some smart contracts could, in fact, function as contracts because in those other cases, at least two willing parties agreed to enter into the contract. But here, with the ownerless immutable smart contracts, “there is no party with which to contract.”

Second, the court held that the immutable smart contracts at issue are not themselves a service but are “more like a tool that is used in performing a service,” which is “not the same as being a service.”

Finally, the court ended with a note on its proper role within our constitutional system of government. It said that while it “readily recognize[s] the real-world downsides of certain uncontrollable technology falling outside of OFAC’s sanctioning authority,” courts “must uphold the statutory bargain struck (or mis-struck) by Congress, not tinker with it.” It declined to engage in “judicial lawmaking” by mending the “statute’s blind spots or smoothing out its disruptive effects.” It said to do so “falls outside of [the court’s] lane” because “Legislating is Congress’s job — and Congress’s alone.”

It’s unclear whether the government will ask the full Fifth Circuit to review the decision or whether it will ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review it. Notably, the Eleventh Circuit still has a similar case pending before it. If it reaches a different conclusion or uses different reasons to reach even the same, or a similar, conclusion, that could motivate the Supreme Court to review the case.

Of course, it will be interesting to see what position the incoming Trump Administration will take on this case too. It may very well be that the new administration will agree that the Biden Administration’s OFAC should not have taken this unprecedented action.

And, of course, Congress could always act too.

So, for now, it’s good news for the crypto community. But the story is far from over.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
NBTC

Related Posts

David Sacks Backs Trump’s GENIUS Act Push to Make US Undisputed Crypto Leader

18/07/2025

SEC commissioner removes head of the PCAOB

18/07/2025

New Reports That Donald Trump May Fire Fed Chairman Jerome Powell – They Held a Meeting Yesterday

18/07/2025

Fidelity Urges Congress to Fix Bitcoin and Crypto Tax Rules as Lawmakers Push New Regulations

18/07/2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Top Posts
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Your source for the serious news. This website is crafted specifically to for crazy and hot cryptonews. Visit our main page for more tons of news.

We're social. Connect with us:

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Top Insights

Kana Labs and Rewardy Wallet Unveil Multi-Chain Swap Experience with Version 1.4.0

18/07/2025

BitMine Immersion Surges 40% After Revealing $500M ETH Treasury

18/07/2025

David Sacks Backs Trump’s GENIUS Act Push to Make US Undisputed Crypto Leader

18/07/2025
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.