Close Menu
  • Coins
    • Bitcoin
    • Ethereum
    • Altcoins
    • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • DeFi
  • Metaverse
  • Regulation
  • Other
    • Exchanges
    • ICO
    • GameFi
    • Mining
    • Legal
  • MarketCap
What's Hot

$3.4B in Ether lost forever due to user errors, Coinbase warns

25/07/2025

96.9% Chance of No Interest Rate Hike

25/07/2025

$BABYDOGE Token Analysis 2025

25/07/2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Back to NBTC homepage
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
X (Twitter) Telegram Facebook LinkedIn RSS
NBTC News
  • Coins
    1. Bitcoin
    2. Ethereum
    3. Altcoins
    4. NFT
    5. View All

    Three Metrics Point to a Big Shift

    25/07/2025

    Bitcoin Sees Long-Term Holders Sell As Short-Term Buyers Step In – Sign Of Rally Exhaustion?

    25/07/2025

    Is MARA Becoming a Shadow Bank Through Its Bitcoin Treasury Strategy?

    24/07/2025

    Bitcoin hits $1T realized cap as price aims to break resistance

    24/07/2025

    $3.4B in Ether lost forever due to user errors, Coinbase warns

    25/07/2025

    Ethereum gained 175% in less than a quarter — and this time, fundamentals showed up

    25/07/2025

    Ethereum price forecast as ETH dominance jumps to 11.5%

    24/07/2025

    Massive 60,991 ETH Transfer: Unraveling the Binance Mystery

    24/07/2025

    $BABYDOGE Token Analysis 2025

    25/07/2025

    Behind the scenes of Solana’s slow validator problem

    25/07/2025

    DeFi Development Unveils International Treasury Platform Built on Solana

    24/07/2025

    TON aims to unlock the next wave of ecosystem growth with Tolk 1.0 launch

    24/07/2025

    Ether Treasury Company GameSquare Buys CryptoPunk NFT for $5.15M

    24/07/2025

    Yuga Labs Bored Ape Yacht Club $9M Win Against Ryder Ripps Overturned, Must Better Prove Trademark Infringement

    24/07/2025

    Disney Eyes Chainlink in New Tech Patent That Bridges NFTs and Real-World Events

    24/07/2025

    Ozzy Osbourne’s passing sparks 400% surge in CryptoBatz NFTs

    23/07/2025

    $3.4B in Ether lost forever due to user errors, Coinbase warns

    25/07/2025

    96.9% Chance of No Interest Rate Hike

    25/07/2025

    $BABYDOGE Token Analysis 2025

    25/07/2025

    SEC Approves, Immediately Pauses Bitwise’s Bid to Convert BITW Crypto Index Fund to ETF

    25/07/2025
  • Blockchain

    Bless Network and Space and Time Partner to Run Verifiable AI Agents on Edge Devices

    24/07/2025

    Brazil’s VERT Debuts Tokenized Credit Platform on XRP Ledger With $130M Issuance

    24/07/2025

    Kalp and Funton.ai Partner to Power Up the Next Wave of Web3 Gaming

    24/07/2025

    Terminus Partners with KaJ Labs to to Power Decentralized Commerce with AI

    24/07/2025

    Zama and OpenZeppelin Team Up to Deliver Confidential Smart Contracts for Institutions

    24/07/2025
  • DeFi

    What’s The Future of Staking and Restaking? Lucio Tato from Meta Pool Provides His Stance

    24/07/2025

    STON.fi and TON Wallet Unite to Bring Telegram-Native DeFi to the U.S

    24/07/2025

    Blazpay Joins Forces with OnlyLayer to Revolutionize Ethereum L2 Scalability

    24/07/2025

    Fees, collateral give DeFi edge as TradFi eyes crypto loans: 1inch exec

    24/07/2025

    AILayer Joins Forces with DotSwap to Power AI-Powered Bitcoin DeFi

    24/07/2025
  • Metaverse

    The Sandbox Launches Largest LAND Auction Using GBM Protocol

    21/07/2025

    Elon Musk’s xAI Quietly Fixed Grok by Deleting a Line of Code

    09/07/2025

    Bonk.fun Grabs 55% of Solana Token Issuance Share, Pushes BONK Demand

    08/07/2025

    Apple’s Top AI Exec Leaves For Meta Amid Aggressive Hiring Trend

    08/07/2025

    Automobili Lamborghini Unveils Digital Temerario and GT3 NFTs in Wilder World

    07/07/2025
  • Regulation

    96.9% Chance of No Interest Rate Hike

    25/07/2025

    Bank of England Governor Doubts the UK Needs a ‘Britcoin’ CBDC

    25/07/2025

    Brazilian Crypto Users Want to Pay with Stablecoins, Survey Shows

    24/07/2025

    PayPal-backed crypto infrastructure firm Talos inks $100M deal to acquire Coin Metrics

    24/07/2025

    Investment Firm Ark Invest Makes Significant Sell-Offs in Both Coinbase Shares and Its Own Spot Bitcoin ETF, ARKB! Details Here

    24/07/2025
  • Other
    1. Exchanges
    2. ICO
    3. GameFi
    4. Mining
    5. Legal
    6. View All

    PayPal World Launch Opens New Paths for Money Transfers

    25/07/2025

    eToro Launches Crypto, Index Futures in Spiner With Lower Minimums

    25/07/2025

    Coinbase launches a paid version: Coinbase One Basic

    24/07/2025

    A New Era for South Korea’s Crypto Landscape

    24/07/2025

    ICO for bitcoin yield farming chain Corn screams we’re so back

    22/01/2025

    Why 2025 Will See the Comeback of the ICO

    26/12/2024

    Axie Infinity Creator Sky Mavis Backs New BORA-Integrated Game on LINE NEXT App

    24/07/2025

    ‘Tokyo Beast’ Speedruns Crypto Game Cycle, Shutting Down Just a Month After Launch

    24/07/2025

    The case for how crypto can Stop Killing Games

    24/07/2025

    FLOKI hints at $75k prize pool, ignites opBNB’s first tournament

    23/07/2025

    Cango finalizes pivot to a Bitcoin mining company

    24/07/2025

    Galaxy Positioned to Capture Favorable Regulatory Upside, Jefferies Says as It Initiates With Buy

    23/07/2025

    Bitcoin Miner Bitfarms Jumps 8% on Share Buyback Program

    22/07/2025

    Bitcoin miner Mawson ousts CEO amid fraud allegations

    22/07/2025

    SEC Approves, Immediately Pauses Bitwise’s Bid to Convert BITW Crypto Index Fund to ETF

    25/07/2025

    South Korea Is Now Fast-Tracking Its Own Crypto Regulations

    24/07/2025

    Will Ripple vs SEC Officially End On August 15?

    24/07/2025

    DOJ Blames Court Error After Trump-Linked Crypto Scam Docket Briefly Sealed

    24/07/2025

    $3.4B in Ether lost forever due to user errors, Coinbase warns

    25/07/2025

    96.9% Chance of No Interest Rate Hike

    25/07/2025

    $BABYDOGE Token Analysis 2025

    25/07/2025

    SEC Approves, Immediately Pauses Bitwise’s Bid to Convert BITW Crypto Index Fund to ETF

    25/07/2025
  • MarketCap
NBTC News
Home»Legal»Crypto Mining Rig Sales Are Securities? Not So Fast, Lawyers Say
Legal

Crypto Mining Rig Sales Are Securities? Not So Fast, Lawyers Say

NBTCBy NBTC03/10/2024No Comments4 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


A federal judge denied a crypto firm’s request last week to dismiss an SEC complaint alleging that the sale of its purported mining hardware to customers constituted an investment contract. And while the move spurred some speculation on social media over the implications for such hardware, legal analysts say there’s no immediate reason for concern.

According to the lawsuit, filed in March 2023 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah, Green United allegedly defrauded investors of $18 million by selling them “Green Boxes” that failed to mine digital tokens called GREEN as promised. That’s because the Ethereum-based tokens couldn’t actually be mined, the suit claims.

The ongoing case forms federal regulators’ latest attempts to eradicate “garden variety fraud” within the cryptocurrency industry and beyond, lawyers told Decrypt.

“They gave people money and they wanted to profit off of it,” said Ishmael Green, a partner at law firm Diaz Reus. “This is a classic fraud case. It’s not even a real [crypto-centric] case.”

Although the lawsuit is another step in the grand scheme of U.S. crypto policy and the SEC’s approach to regulation by enforcement, another lawyer argued to Decrypt that it’s not as consequential to the future of the cryptocurrency industry as the agency’s litigation against Coinbase or Ripple.

“All of these cases are important, but this one is far less important,” said Terrence Yang, strategic advisor at Swan Bitcoin.

Given that Green United’s motion to dismiss the case has been denied, the lawsuit will go on to be heard in a federal court.

In its complaint, the SEC alleges the Green United deposited GREEN tokens into investors’ accounts “to create the appearance of a successful mining operation,” despite the fact that GREEN tokens, which are Ethereum-based ERC-20 tokens, could not be mined and did not come from mining-related activities at all.

The SEC also alleges that GREEN has no realizable value “contrary to representations made [by Green United] at the time” of its hardware’s sale. Green United has denied those allegations in a separate legal filing, however.

Ishmael Green, the Diaz Reus partner, told Decrypt that the SEC’s case is unlikely to have implications for typical mining hardware, which users operate to support networks and try to generate crypto rewards—like on Bitcoin. In this specific case, the SEC is alleging that mining wasn’t actually happening on the boxes sold to users.

It’s fine “so long as the mining rigs are sold with the understanding that the end user will be doing the mining,” he clarified, based on his understanding of the case. “In Green United, the mining rig was sold with an agreement that stated Green United would control and run the system,” he added.

The lawsuit also contains allegations that Green United’s so-called mining equipment—both the hardware (the boxes) and software (the nodes)—comprise a securities investment. That means the case could potentially have implications for hosted mining services, which Green United purported to offer, even though the SEC didn’t explicitly mention hosted mining in its complaint, Reed Smith counsel Hadas Jacobi told Decrypt.

In a posted statement, Green United attempted to paint the SEC’s case as a mischaracterization of what was actually happening, writing that SEC lawyers “try to change the law by classifying hosted mining as a security, a practice performed by numerous public companies.” Green United also said that it offered refunds to buyers, but that “only a very small minority of node owners requested a refund.”

Neither the SEC nor Green United responded to Decrypt‘s requests for comment.

While the SEC and Green United are still locking horns about the legitimacy of the crypto firm’s business and the classification of its mining equipment, the judge overseeing the case is far from making any determinations, lawyers told Decrypt.

“The recent ruling… makes a much more limited determination,” Jacobi said.

According to Jacobi, the judge’s rejection of Green United’s motion to dismiss the case isn’t a ruling in favor of the SEC’s arguments, but rather a declaration that he simply intends to hear the case instead of throwing it out.

Green United’s unsuccessful attempt to dismiss the case isn’t much of a surprise, as firms commonly request dismissals, according to lawyers that spoke to Decrypt. That’s because filing such a request typically has benefits for defendants, regardless of whether or not they have actually violated federal securities laws.

Filing to dismiss a case “is almost like getting two bites at the apple for doing the bare minimum,” Green told Decrypt. “The [defense] receives additional time, and they also get to come up with additional legal theories as to why they’re innocent.”

Edited by Andrew Hayward

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
NBTC

Related Posts

SEC Approves, Immediately Pauses Bitwise’s Bid to Convert BITW Crypto Index Fund to ETF

25/07/2025

South Korea Is Now Fast-Tracking Its Own Crypto Regulations

24/07/2025

Will Ripple vs SEC Officially End On August 15?

24/07/2025

DOJ Blames Court Error After Trump-Linked Crypto Scam Docket Briefly Sealed

24/07/2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Top Posts
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Your source for the serious news. This website is crafted specifically to for crazy and hot cryptonews. Visit our main page for more tons of news.

We're social. Connect with us:

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Top Insights

$3.4B in Ether lost forever due to user errors, Coinbase warns

25/07/2025

96.9% Chance of No Interest Rate Hike

25/07/2025

$BABYDOGE Token Analysis 2025

25/07/2025
Get Informed

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from NBTC regarding crypto, blockchains and web3 related topics.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.